Dear Sen. Harkin, These Are Terrible Materials For Building A Starter Home

Sen. Tom Harkin continues to refer to the Senate health reform bill as a “starter home” in a new entry on the Huffington Post.
Instead of that "partial loaf" analogy, I like to think of this bill as like a starter home. It is not the mansion of our dreams. But it has a solid foundation, giving every American access to quality, affordable coverage. It has an excellent, protective roof, which will shelter Americans from the worst abuses of health insurance companies. And this starter home has plenty of room for additions and improvements.

This bill has a terrible foundation. It is a starter home built with the equivalent of toxic drywall, lead paint, a poorly mixed cement foundation, and faulty electric wiring.

The bill is built on the extremely wasteful and inefficient private insurance system and contains one of the biggest rollbacks in decades of women's reproductive rights. It, in effect, gives a permanent exclusivity to expensive biologics, and still denies Americans the ability to buy cheaper drugs from overseas. It has insufficient regulations and leaves the regulator enforcement purely up to the states, which have a poor track record enforcing the current regulations on their books. Regulation without enforcement is worthless. It throws good money after bad without fixing the underlying problems. The cost of the insurance will be too high and the quality of the insurance is too low. Funneling billions of dollars and forcing millions of Americans to buy a product that is frankly a terrible bargain is not a good foundation to build on. It is only a good foundation for the private insurance companies because it further enriches and entrenches them. Rewarding the failure of the private health insurance system with even more money and more customers is not how you want to build your “starter home.”

Harkin is definitely correct when he says, “a starter home has plenty of room for additions and improvements.” There are many, many, many problems with this bill that need to be corrected. Unfortunately, no one is going to want to put additions on a terribly built home, and no one is going to want to rehire the same contractor that so completely botched the construction of the home to build the addition. I would love it if this were a smaller home, but built with a sturdy foundation.

In reality, what we have is a massive corporate giveaway that will serve to discredit the “progressive" principles that Harkin falsely claims this thing is built on. Teddy Roosevelt was the progressive trust buster. It makes a mockery of the term “progressive” to claim a plan to force Americans to buy expensive, low-quality goods from insurance companies exempt form anti-trust laws (laws that Roosevelt championed) and subsidized with taxpayer money is in anyway “progressive.”

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

This kind of 'kill the bill' purism is reminiscent of the purism that propelled some to back Nader in 2000. Purism that led to thousands of deaths in Iraq and Afghanistan, and many more here in the US for want of insurance, because Nader cost a smart man - and future Nobel laureate - the Presidency of this land.

No wonder much of the Left blogosphere - not exactly Obama-worshipping, if you will - is uniting against the Norquist-supporting Firedoglake.

If progressive Democrats don't do well in the midterms, it will be because of people like you. Are you ready for the blame, John?

KingCranky II said...

Typical DLC bs, can't disprove Walker's point, pulls the "Nader" card.

I don't trust the Obama Administration when it comes to aggressive criminal prosecutions or drastic civil sanctions/fines, both of which are the ONLY way to keep the health insurers in line.

No prosecutions of Bush Jr (warrantless spying, torture), financial services industry (economic meltdown) or Halliburton/KBR (war profiteering) bears out the above point completely, yet, somehow, Obama will keep the health insurers honest without keeping them on as short and tight a leash as possible.

You keep right on wishing that, and maybe your unicorn will be a solid gold one too.

Typical "must not question Obama" lackey, just as irritating as the Bush Jr lackeys, and this constant liberal bashing by the Obama Administration & Democratic leadership apologists will do more to get Republicans elected than anything else, there's no reason for the liberal or labor unions-you know, the Democrats base-to do GOTV if all that happens is they get slapped around by the Obama Administration and Democratic leadership, as there's NO point in electing Democrats who worry more about appeasing the GOP and its wingnut, secession loony and gun toting thug base than they do about living up to their own campaign pledges and Democratic party platform.

Steve said...

Do you need to find Encino dentists that are going to be caring and kind to your teeth? Then go with these guys, they’re the best in the area.

Anonymous said...

Great info, thanks for posting. This helped me know more about security and how monitored security could work for me.

Anonymous said...

Interesting thoughts. This article had some great info, thanks for the post. When I needed to go to an addiction center I found many great resources on the web.

Grace Lee said...

Being a malpractice lawyer I found this article to be very informative. Help is out there and it’s easier to find if you know what you’re looking for.

stacy said...

Thanks for the helpful info. When I learned about retreats for healing it changed my life.

Tina said...

Don’t let addiction take over your life. You can get eating disorder treatment today. Turn to someone who can help.

Steve said...

Thanks for the helpful info. When I learned about getting a sober coach it changed my life.

John said...

Great info, thanks for posting. This helped me know more about solar panel installations cost. Good luck on your research.

Brian said...

When I broke down on the Lonestar run I need motorcycle towing that I could trust and these guys were the ones to help me out.

stacy said...

This article had great info on looking for a solar lease. Check them out.

Tony Raz said...

Thanks for the info. It can be hard figuring out from all the internet marketing firms which one will work for you. Do your research and I’m sure you’ll find someone that works.

stacy said...

Thanks for the info. It can be really hard getting help for addiction. I was looking for weed detox and found many useful resources on the web.

cerebral palsy in babies said...

Great post.

brian7 said...

Thanks for the helpful info. When I learned about getting a sober coach it changed my life.

John said...

Great post and informative. Finding the right abogado is very important when you need to deal with a law situation.

Tina said...

I was facing addiction and wanted to go to a teen rehab. These guys are the best and the really know how to help a person grow.

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...